41.2 F
Tuesday, September 22, 2020

For or Against: Should the Detroit Tigers sign Troy Tulowitzki?

Since the news was released that All-Star shortstop, Troy Tulowitzki, was released from the Toronto Blue Jays, speculation began to arise as to where he would sign —  not if he would sign. On December 18th, Tulowitzki held a private work out with 11 teams in attendance.

One of those teams was the Detroit Tigers.

Does a Tulowitzki to the Tigers deal make sense? Let’s divide out the arguments.

For Signing Tulo –

For a stretch of years, Tulo was arguably the best shortstop in all of baseball. Compiling a career WAR of 44.1, five All-Star appearances, two-time Gold Glover, and multiple Silver Sluggers, Tulo is a 12-year veteran that has postseason experience.

Even better, when the Blue Jays cut Tulo, they still are on the hook for his $38 million over the next two years. This is a simple low-risk, possible reward situation for the Tigers. For a team that signed Jordy Mercer to a one-year deal, and who have yet to decide who will man the keystone for 2019, signing Tulowitzki does make sense. Especially given the price tag, veteran presence, and defensive need he would be. A middle infield of Mercer and Tulo could be a great bridge to the prospects littered in the Tigers minor league system.

This could definitely be the move for the Tigers, given the production Tulo could bring, they could potentially flip him at the deadline to a contender for more prospects. Especially given the salary he’ll be paid, he could be very, very valuable.

Against Signing Tulo –

The defensive upgrade and price tag aside, Tulo does come with some baggage. This is why signing Tulowitzki isn’t so much of a no-brainer. It has been well documented that he has faced his fair share of injuries since 2012.

This is the major hangup for signing Tulowitzki, will he be healthy enough to become that valuable trade chip come the end of July. Since 2011, when he played in 143 games, the former All-Star has only once (2016, 131) played more than 130 games in a season; not to mention, four out of those seven years brought a games-played-total of fewer than 100 games. There’s a very good chance the “risk” would be in the fact Tulowitzki would not be moved at the deadline and the Tigers would be forced to either play him or cut him come August.

There is no way to truly say one way or the other if signing Tulowitzki would be a good choice for the Detroit Tigers. There’s good to it, there are drawbacks to it. Does the possible reward of a trade piece outweigh the possible risk of not being able to move him at all, and him blocking a position at the end of the season?

That’s the million dollar question.

Let us know what you think!

- Advertisement -

Top Stories

Major positive emerges from Detroit Lions embarrassing loss to Packers

For those of you who watched the Detroit Lions latest collapse, this time blowing a 14-3 lead to the Green Bay Packers, you would...

Detroit Pistons great Isiah Thomas continues to diss Michael Jordan

When it comes to the "Who is the greatest NBA player of all-time" debate, there are generally two players who are in the conversation. Those...

CBS writer Jon Rothstein releases Big Ten basketball preseason Power Rankings

College basketball returns on November 25! http://gty.im/1096186106 We here in Big Ten country will be paying attention to the Michigan State Spartans and the Michigan...

Fan releases Trevor Lawrence Detroit Lions edit [Photo]

Well, we are only two games into the Detroit Lions 2020 regular season and many fans are already thinking about the 2021 NFL draft. For...

Report: Red Wings to make ‘big pitch’ for goaltender Jacob Markstrom

The Detroit Red Wings are going to be in the market for goaltending assistance this offseason, as long-tenured veteran Jimmy Howard, who won't be...

Related news

Jim Leyland weighs in on Detroit Tigers managerial search

Ron Gardenhire has decided to retire from baseball and we now know the Detroit Tigers will have a new manager in 2020, whether it...

Ron Gardenhire reveals his preference for next Detroit Tigers manager

Detroit Tigers manager Ron Gardenhire stunned his team over the weekend when he announced his retirement due to health reasons. http://gty.im/1228603704 Gardenhire appeared on "The Morning...

Detroit Tigers option Sergio Alcantara to Toledo, corresponding move coming prior to Tuesday’s game

The Detroit Tigers weren't able to take care of business this afternoon against the Cleveland Indians, falling by a 7-4 final score. http://gty.im/1228625481 Afterwards, the...

Miguel Cabrera blasts career HR No. 484, trails Gehrig by only 9 (VIDEO)

Detroit Tigers slugger Miguel Cabrera continues to climb the MLB stats ladder. http://gty.im/1228535957 The future Hall of Famer hit his 484th career home run this afternoon...
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap