9. Justin Herbert – Los Angeles Chargers

PFF 2024 Grade: 91.2 (Overall), 89.8 (Passing)
Statistically strong as ever, Herbert remains one of the most talented passers in the league, but the criticism persists: where are the big-time wins? His QBR (64.8) was respectable, and his passing grade was excellent, but the offense sputtered late in games. With Jim Harbaugh at the helm and a revamped run game, 2025 might be the year Herbert finally breaks through the wall and becomes more than just an arm talent.