41.2 F
Detroit
Tuesday, August 11, 2020

Writer believes 2 former Detroit Tigers should be out of Hall of Fame, while one should be added

Around these parts, there is little argument that former Detroit Tigers 2B Lou Whitaker deserves to be in the Baseball Hall of Fame, yet, he has fallen short of getting the nod.

According to Radio.com writer Jordan Cohn, Whitaker should be in (instead of Bill Mazeroski) but two other former Tigers who are currently in the Hall of Fame are not deserving.

Here is Cohn’s rationale for Whitaker being in over Mazerowski:

Instead of the face of NL second basemen in the 60s, let’s put in the face of AL second basemen in the 80s. Sweet Lou’s career WAR (75.1) is a top-80 figure of all time and literally doubles Mazeroski’s… and then some. After Alan Trammell was inducted in the Class of 2018, the conversation about Whitaker’s candidacy rose to new highs, and it’s only right that the other half of that famous double-play duo should be enshrined as well (why else are Tinker, Evers and Chance in the Hall?). But Lou provided pop, too, with four Silver Slugger awards and nearly 250 career round trippers to go along with solid speed, great run-scoring production and more career walks than strikeouts.

The two former Tigers Cohn believes should be replaced are George Kell and Jack Morris.

Here is Cohn’s reasoning for Kell, who he believes should be replaced by Steve Garvey.

Kell earned 10 All Star selections in his big league career which is undeniably impressive. He was a very difficult guy to strike out and was capable of providing extra-base pop, leading the league in doubles twice (in the same years that he also led in hits). But outright dominance? I don’t really see it, other than the short span from 1949-1951 when he was at his peak. He was never a power hitter, topping 10 home runs only once in a season. His fielding was rather unremarkable (dWAR of 1.6 in his career). His OPS never broke .900. And his career WAR of 37.6 is 584th among all Major Leaguers, which continues the chain of underwhelming stats.

Cohn did not give a reason for Morris being replaced but he believes Ron Guidry is more deserving.

Nation, do you agree with Cohn?

- Advertisement -
Don Drysdale
I am a fan of all Detroit sports and LOVE to write about them!

Latest news

3-star TE Jake Renda decides to spurn Michigan State, chooses Pittsburgh instead

3-star tight tend Jake Renda has decided to de-commit from the Michigan State Spartans, with whom he had committed to play last month. Instead,...
- Advertisement -

JaCoby Jones hits Tigers’ first inside-the-park home run since 2017 [Video]

The Detroit Tigers are having some fun right now and that fun continued on Monday night when JaCoby Jones hit an inside-the-park home run...

Detroit Tigers’ C.J. Cron helped off the field after taking ball off his left leg

The Detroit Tigers appear to have lost a big piece of their lineup tonight against the Chicago White Sox. C.J. Cron has left the game...

NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman: Draft Lottery process “was fair”

NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman decided to pour a little salt in the wounds of Detroit Red Wings fans everywhere when he offered his thoughts...

Related news

Oakland A’s Ramon Laureano has harsh words for Astros coach Alex Cintron after brawl

The Houston Astros are already facing some justice being taken into the hands of the players themselves following their well-documented sign stealing scandal. On...

JaCoby Jones hits Tigers’ first inside-the-park home run since 2017 [Video]

The Detroit Tigers are having some fun right now and that fun continued on Monday night when JaCoby Jones hit an inside-the-park home run...

Detroit Tigers’ C.J. Cron helped off the field after taking ball off his left leg

The Detroit Tigers appear to have lost a big piece of their lineup tonight against the Chicago White Sox. C.J. Cron has left the game...

Flashback: Miguel Cabrera makes history against New York’s Mariano Rivera (VIDEO)

He was less than a year removed from his historic Triple Crown season in 2012 when he made some addition history against a future...
>

Don't miss any of the action!

Wake up each morning with a daily dose of vitamin DSN with the top articles from the previous day sent right to your inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!